Water Witch Menus





Carnation Coral $13

Sweet and sour, fruity and bubbly, charmingly pink
Vodka, Limoncello, Fassionola, Falernum, Lemon, Rose Water, Soda

The Devil's Hourglass $14

Balanced Mezcal Punch
Black Sesame-infused Mezcal, Tequila, Aperol, Lime, Mango, Soy

Jamaican Bobsled $14

Tropic medley right where it belongs
Navy Strength Jamaican Rum, Black Rum, Strawberry,
Pineapple Tea, Lime

Jupiter $14

Rye, nutmeg, and maple spice up a Saturn
Nutmeg Rye, Maple, Fernet, Lemon, Passionfruit, Orgeat
Add spice with a shot of Underberg Bitters for $6

La Noche Agridulce $13

Paloma on a bender
Water Witch Grapefruit-cello Tequila, Lime, Grapefruit, Lilly Root Shrub

Penelope's Lament $12

Summery, rosé sangria, served in shark.
White & Rosé Wine, Passion Fruit, Rum, Mango, Raspberry, Mint

Serrano Seafoam $14

Fizzy, foamy, merry and bright
Vodka, Serrano Aperol, Montenegro, Orange, Club Soda

Stilleto $12

Pretty summer punch with just a hint of fluffy
Water Witch Blackberry Gin, Orgeat, Cocchi, Lemon

Sundress $11

Fresh and bitter licorice-summer cooler
Anise-infused Vodka, Campari, Coconut, Grenadine, Lime, hint of Chili

Velvet Mongoose $14

Sweet and creamy fruit coquito
Rhum Agricole, Coconut Creme, Peach, Orgeat, Lime


Bad Habit $14

A bittersweet Rum riff on the classic Manhattan
White Rum, Aged Rum, Cynar, Apricot Brandy, Rouge Vermouth,
Orange Bitters, Absinthe

Betty's Accusation $13

Delicate, pretty, and out to get you
Rose-infused Gin, Blanc Vermouth, Peychaud's Bitters, Sichuan Pepper Tincture

Mortar and Pesto $12

The dirtiest rum martini
Pesto fat-washed English-style rum, Cocchi Americano, Dry Curaçao

Water Witch Classics

Banana Spliff (Smoked) $14

Spirited, spiced and smoky, with just a bit of banana
Bourbon, Spiced Rum, Banana Rum, Prohibition Bitters

Espresso Mar-TIKI $11

Coffee Martini with an Island Twist
Water Witch Spiced Rum & Banana Rum, Coffee Liqueur, Orgeat

Piña Colada Clarified Milk Punch $11

Pleasingly Sweet, Funky, and nowhere close to caught in the rain
Rum, Pineapple, Coconut, Lime (vegan)
Milk clarification is a historic process for preserving cocktails -- a prepared cocktail reacts with milk (in this case coconut milk) to form solids which are used to strain out perishable compounds and transform the finished product.

Tiki Classics

Jungle Bird $14

An original tiki punch, bitter and sweet
Dark Jamaican Rum, Campari, Pineapple, Lime, Simple Syrup

Mai Tai $14

The original, made just how it should be
Jamaican Rum, Rhum Agricole, Dry Curacao, Orgeat, Lime

Painkiller $13

Sweet and creamy
Black Rum, Pineapple, Coconut, Orange

Naked Ape $12

Rich and sticky spiced banana
Blackstrap Rum, Banana Rum, Overproof Rum, Cinnamon, Lemon, Angostura Bitters

Saturn $11

Gin and passionfruit, sweet and tart
Gin, Falernum, Orgeat, Passion Fruit, Lemon

Halekulani $13

Tiki meets bourbon with a good hit of pineapple
Bonded Bourbon, Pina, Orange, Demerara, Angostura

Scorpion Reef $13

A slightly smoky classic tiki punch
Rum, Mezcal, Pina, Lemon, Orgeat, Angostura, Mole

Daiquiri $9

Upgrade to your rum of choice for a bit more
White Rum, Lime, Demerara Syrup


Beach Fuzz $8

Bellini with just the right amount of bitter
Peach, Lime, Aperitif, Soda

Freshly Brewed Hot Coffee $4.5

Freshly brewed filter coffee
Sweetener available upon request

Husky Voice $8

Bright and fresh pineapple rickey
Pineapple, Lemon, Husk Syrup, Soda

Palmas del Mar $8

Creamy & tart strawberry soda
Strawberry Cordial, Vanilla, Soda

Passiflora $8

Tropical old fashioned-style sipper
Hibiscus Tea, Passion Fruit, Cinnamon, Jamaican Bitters


Squall $6

Bite-sized hurricanes
Rum, Aperol, Fassionola, Lime

Lem-k-lele $6

Far more interesting then a lemon drop
Vodka, Limoncello, Lemon, Peaflower

Pisco Alejandro $6

If a mango lassi were a cocktail
Pisco, Yoghurt Liqueur, Mango, Orange

Shark Attack $6

Mini margaritas with blood in the water
Tequila, Blue Curacao, Lime, Hibiscus Syrup


Summer Sun Clarified Milk Punch $12

Mild, clean, and refreshing tequila punch made with fresh milk
Tequila, Mint, Framboise, Lime

Party Bowls

Bowls each contain a bit over 4 servings.

The Fate of the Water Witch $45

Warm, rich, and easy to love
Black Rum, Water Witch Banana Rum, Pimento Dram, Pineapple, Lime, Coconut, Cinnamon, Bitters

Myanmar Beach $41

Mango mojito with sparking wine
White Rum, Mango, Lime, Mint, Sparkling Wine

“Bowl” any House Cocktail

Ask when ordering!
Multiple orders of house cocktails can be combined into bowls 

Hard Cider & Beer


Miller High Life (Pony) $4
American Lager, 4.6%, 7oz bottle, Milwaukee

Pacífico $6 
Cerveza, 4.5%, 12oz can, Ciudad de México

Southbound - Mountain Jam $8
Pale Lager, 5.1%, 12oz can, Savannah

Sweetwater Lager $5
American Lager, 4.5%, 12oz can, Atlanta

Tecate $5
Cerveza, 4.5%, 16oz can, Monterrey

Tecate Light $5
Light Cerveza, 3.9%, 12oz can, Monterrey


Dogfish Head - Slightly Mighty $7
Session IPA, 4%, 12oz can, Delaware

Goat Island - Goatopia - NEIPA $8
New England IPA, 6.2%, 12oz can, Alabama

Montauk - Wave Chaser $8
American IPA, 6.4%, 12oz can, New York

Southbound - Cosmic Howdy $9
New England IPA, 6.8%, 12oz can, Savannah


Goat Island - Blood Orange $8
Sour Berliner Weisse, 5%, 12oz can, Alabama

Southbound - Islandia $9
Fruited Sour, 5.3%, 12oz can, Savannah

Other Ale

Dogfish Head - Citrus Squall $7
Fruited Golden Ale, 8%, 12oz can, Delaware

Goat Island - Peace, Love And Hippieweizen $7
Hefeweizen, 5.5%, 12oz can, Alabama

Maui - Pineapple Mana Wheat $7
Fruited Wheat Beer, 5.5%, 12oz can, Hawai'i


Atlanta - Tapache $12
Pineapple Cider, 5%, 16oz can

Original Sin - Black Widow $8
Blackberry Hard Cider, 6%, 12oz can, New York




Mutiny Island

Old 4th 

10th Mountain

Ahus Akvavit


Hanson Habanero Organic Vodka

Crystal Head


Hamilton Demerara

Ron Matusalem Platino

Saison Pale

Cruzan Black Strap

Kula Toasted Coconut

Plantation 3 Star

Ron Abuelo Anejo

Lemon Hart 1804

Ten To One Caribbean White

Gosling’s Black Seal

Havana Club Anejo

Don Q Gold

Blackwell Jamaican

Don Q 7


St. James Blanc

St. James Paille Gold

Diplomatico Mantuano

St. Lucia Chairman’s Reserve

Alander Spiced

Chairman's Reserve

SelvaRey Cacao

SelvaRey Coconut

Alander Aged Rum

Kirk & Sweeney 12 Yr


Plantation Pineapple

Smith and Cross

Tiki Lovers Pineapple

Pusser’s British Navy

JM Rhum Agricole

Paranubes Oaxaca


Ron del Barrilito 3 Star

Real McCoy 5 Yr

Ten To One Caribbean Dark

Diplomatico Reserva

Canada Aguardiente De Oaxaca

Santa Teresa 1796 Solera

RL Seales 12 Year

Don Q Grand Reserve Anejo XO

Joel Richard Esencia 25 Yr

Worthy Park Habitation Velier Forsyth

Barrell Rum

E Leon Jimenes Rum

Hampden Estate Great House 2022

Four Square ECS Shibboleth

Hampden Estate 2010

Foursquare ECS Mark XXII Touchstone


Dampfwerk London Dry 

Tyler's City of London


St. George Terroir


Bimini Coconut 

Old Fourth

Manly Lilly Pilly Pink 

Solveig Anna's Garden



The Botanist Islay Dry 

Silent Pool

Glendalough Wild Botanical

Sipsmith Sloe

Isle of Harris

Rabbit Hole Bespoke

Tequila & Mezcal

El Jimador Silver

Playa Real Reposado

Cazadores Blanco


Casa Mexico Blanco


Yuu Baal Joven Mezcal

Yuu Baal Reposado Mezcal

Tapatio Reposado

La Gritona Reposado

Casa Mexico Reposado

Prospero Blanco

Curamia Blanco

Dona Vega Joven Mezcal

Prospero Reposado

Metiche Salmiana Mezcal

Pierde Almas La Puritita Verda Mezcal

Dos Primos Blanco

Casamigos Blanco

Curamia Reposado

Tanteo Jalapeno Tequila

Vago Mezcal Espadin Emigdio Jarquin

Vago Mezcal Espadin Joel Barriga

Tromba Anejo

Lobos Joven Tequila

El Pintor Blanco

Tapatio Anejo

Don Julio Blanco

Aqara Agave de Los Andes Reposado

Vago Mezcal Elote

Lalo Blanco

Ocho Plata

El Tequileno Reposado Gran Reserva

Patron Reposado

Mezcal Legendario Domingo Guerrero Cuprento

Patron Anejo

Casamigos Anejo

Codigo 1530 Rosa

Cincoro Blanco

Penta Diamante Reposado Cristalino

Don Julio Alma Miel

Patron Extra Anejo

Komos Reposado Rosa

Dona Vega Tabala

Patron El Cielo

Codigo 1530 Anejo

Don Julio 1942 Limited


Slane Irish Whiskey

Four Roses Yellow Label

Proper No Twelve

Old Grand Dad

Harleston Green Scotch

Rittenhouse Rye

Sazerac Rye 6 Year

Powers Gold Irish Whiskey

Rowan’s Creek

Abasolo Ancestral Corn Mexican Whisky

Teeling Small Batch

Traverse City XXX Straight Bourbon

Three Chord Small Batch Bourbon

Woodford Reserve Bourbon

Woodford Reserve Rye

Woodford Reserve Malt

Sheep Dip

Short Barrel Bourbon Bark Batch

Redwood Empire Emerald Giant Rye

Town Branch Rye

Uncle Nearest 1884 Small Batch

Four Roses Small Batch Select

Bluffton Whiskey

Heaven's Door Straight Bourbon

Basil Hayden Toast Bourbon

10th Mountain Rye

Old 4th Rye

Wild Turkey 101

Angel’s Envy

Blade & Bow

Teeling Single Malt

Woodford Reserve Double Oak Bourbon

Short Barrel Rye 101

Few Cold Cut Bourbon

Chicken Cock Bourbon

Stagg Jr.

Brenne Estate Single Malt Whiskey

Old 4th Bottled In Bond Bourbon

Whistle Pig Rye Roadstock

EH Taylor Single Barrel

Bruichladdich Classic Laddie

Old Pepper Rye

Rabbit Hole Cavehill Bourbon

Whistlepig Farmstock Rye

Benriach 12 YR Smoky Single Malt Scotch

Nelson Brothers Sherry Cask Finish Bourbon

Whistle Pig Rye 10 Year

Jefferson's Ocean Bourbon

Thomas Handy Sazarac Rye

Short Barrel The Bees Knees

Chicken Cock Island Rooster Rye

Whistle Pig Rye 15 Year

Compass Box Ultramarine


Duc de Valmer Brut, FR $6

Bach Rose Cava, ES $9

The Pale Rose, FR $10

O&T Touraine, FR $9

Maddalena Chardonnay, CA $9

Chemistry Willamette Pinot Noir, OR $13

Turning Tide Cabernet Sauvignon, CA $12

Happy Hour

Happy Hour

Prices valid for 5pm-7pm Monday to Friday

Tecate/Tecate Light $3

The Pale Rose, FR $8

Chemistry Willamette, Pinot Noir, OR $11

Fire Witch Margarita $9 

A tart and warm people-pleaser
Tequila, Cinnamon, Orange

Tybee Sunset $9 

Sweet tropical fruit punch
Vodka, Orgeat, Lemon, Pineapple, Hibiscus Syrup

Ardsley Park $9 

A color changing tart and earthy drink
Gin, Peaflower, Mint, Lime



Supplies Limited!

Barnacles $1.50

Spiced oyster crackers

Devil Nuts $1.50

Chili peanuts

Rosemary Cashews $1.50

Cashews in a rosemary spice blend

Spicy Pretzels $1.50

Pretzels in spice blend. Hot!

Assortment $5

All four of the above.

Hurricane Chips $3

House Specials

Fassionola Salsa $7

House made salsa with fassionola fruit, onion, lime, bell peppers, habenero peppers, tomatoes. Served with corn chips.

Skillet Cookie $4

Warm cookie with pineapple, miso, white and milk chocolate chips, macadamia nuts.

Signup For News And Specials